Formation of Causal and Systemic Relations in the Ukrainian and Russian Comparative Studies in 20th – 60th of the XIX c

  • V.A. Glushchenko K.A. Tyshchenko
Keywords: comparative linguistics, principle of historical development, principle of causality, systemic principle, principle of general connection of phenomena

Abstract

The article shows that the formation of a comparative-historical method and the principles of comparative-historical research took place in the works of Ukrainian and Russian linguists of the 20th – 60th of the ХІХ century. It has been noted that the leading role belonged to the principle of historical development, but other principles (causality, systemic, general connection of phenomena) also played an important role. The division of the causes of the development of language into internal and external was of great importance was. It has been established that in the XIX century the most significant results in the knowledge of the systemic properties of language belonged precisely to comparative-historical linguistics. Within its limits, the view of language as a systemic phenomenon has spread. It has been proved that the contribution of linguists of this period to the development of the principles of comparative-historical linguistics was significant.

References

1. Budagov R.A. Sistema i antisistema v nauke o yazyke [System and antisystem in the science of language] / R.A. Budagov // Voprosy yazykoznaniya. – 1978. – No. 4. – S. 3–17.



2. Budde Ye.F. O zaslugakh Buslaeva kak uchenogo lingvista i prepodavatelya [About Buslaev’s merits as a scientist linguist and teacher] (Rech, chitannaya v torzhestvennom zasedanii Kazanskogo obshchestva arkheologii, istorii i etnografii 28 sentyabrya 1897 goda) / Ye. F. Budde // Prepodavanie otechestvennogo yazyka: [ucheb. posobie dlya studentov ped. in-tov po spets. “Rus. yaz. i lit.”]. – M.: Prosveshchenie, 1992. – S. 480–493.



3. Buslaev F.I. Istoricheskaya grammatika russkogo yazyka [Historical grammar of the Russian language] / F.I. Buslaev. – M.: Uchpedgiz, 1959. – 623 s.



4. Buslaev F.I. O prepodavanii otechestvennogo yazyka [On the teaching of the native language] / F.I. Buslaev // Prepodavanie otechestvennogo yazyka: [ucheb. posobie dlya studentov ped. in-tov po spets. “Rus. yaz. i lit.”]. – M.: Prosveshchenie, 1992. – S. 25–373.



5. Vostokov A.Kh. Rassuzhdenie o slavyanskom yazyke, sluzhashchee vvedeniem k grammatike sego yazyka, sostavlyaemoy po drevneyshim onogo pismennym pamyatnikam [Contemplation about the Slavic language, which can serve as an introduction to the grammar of this language, compiled on the basis of the oldest written monuments] / A.Kh. Vostokov // Filologicheskie nablyudeniya / Izdal, po porucheniyu 2-go otdeleniya Akademii nauk, I. Sreznevskiy. – SPb., 1865. – S. 1–27.



6. Glushchenko V.A. Porivnialno-istorychnyi metod v ukrainskomu ta rosiiskomu movoznavstvi 20-kh – 60-kh rr. ХІХ st.: [navchalnyi posibnyk dlia zdobuvachiv filolohichnykh fakultetiv] [The comparative-historical method of Ukrainian and Russian linguistics of the 20’s – 60’s of the XIX century: [teaching aid for postgraduate applicants in philology]] / V.A. Glushchenko, K.A. Tyshchenko. – Sloviansk, 2016. – 98 s.



7. Glushchenko V.A. Pryntsypy porivnialno-istorychnoho doslidzhennia v ukrainskomu i rosiiskomu movoznavstvi (70-i rr. ХIХ st. – 20-i rr. ХХ st.) [The principles of the comparative-historical research of Ukrainian and Russian linguistics (70th of the XIX century – 20th of the XX century)] / Volodymyr Andriiovych Glushchenko / NAN Ukrainy, In-t movoznavstva im. O.O. Potebni; [vidp. red. O.B. Tkachenko]. – Donetsk, 1998. – 222 s.



8. Grech N.I. Chteniya o russkom yazyke [Readings on the Russian Language] / N.I. Grech. – SPb., 1840. – Ch. 1. – VI, 336 s.; Ch. 2. – 404 s.



9. Zhuravlev V.K. Vnutrennyaya rekonstruktsiya [Internal reconstruction] / V.K. Zhuravlev // Sravnitelno-istoricheskoe izuchenie yazykov raznykh semey: teoriya lingvisticheskoy rekonstruktsii. – M.: Nauka, 1988. – S. 68–90.



10. Zhuravlev V.K. Nauka o praslavyanskom yazyke: evolyutsiya idey, ponyatiy i metodov [The science of the Proto-Slavic language: the evolution of ideas, concepts and methods] / V.K. Zhuravlev // Birnbaum Kh. Praslavyanskiy yazyk: dostizheniya i problemy v ego rekonstruktsii / [obshch. red. V.A. Dybo i V.K. Zhuravleva]. – M.: Progress, 1987. – S. 453–493.



11. Zvegintsev V.A. Ocherki po obshchemu yazykoznaniyu [Essays on general linguistics] / V.A. Zvegintsev. – M.: Izd-vo Mosk. un-ta, 1962. – 384 s.



12. Zubkova L.G. Lingvisticheskie ucheniya kontsa XVIII – nachala XX v.: razvitie obshchey teorii yazyka v sistemnykh kontseptsiyakh [Linguistic researches of the late XVIII – early XX century: development of the general theory of language in the systemic concepts] / L.G. Zubkova. – M.: Izd-vo Un-ta druzhby narodov, 1989. – 215 s.



13. Istrina Ye.S. Trudy A.A. Shakhmatova po russkomu yazyku [Works by A.A. Shakhmatov on the Russian language] / Ye.S. Istrina // Izv. Otd-niya rus. yaz. i slovesnosti. – 1922. – T. 25 (1920 g.). – S. 100–106.



14. Kolesov V.V. Stanovlenie idei razvitiya v russkom yazykoznanii pervoy poloviny XIX v. [Formation of the idea of development in Russian linguistics in the first half of the 19th century] / V.V Kolesov // Ponimanie istorizma i razvitiya v yazykoznanii pervoy poloviny XIX veka / [otv. red. A.V. Desnitskaya]. – L.: Nauka, 1984. – S. 163–199.



15. Kubryakova Ye.S. O ponyatiyakh yazykovoy sistemy i struktury yazyka [On the concepts of the language system and the structure of the language] / Ye.S. Kubryakova, G.P. Melnikov // Obshchee yazykoznanie: vnutrennyaya struktura yazyka / [otv. red. B.A. Serebrennikov]. – M.: Nauka, 1972. – S. 8–91.



16. Kuznetsov I.V. Kategoriya prichinnosti i ee poznavatelnoe znachenie [The category of causality and its cognitive meaning] / I.V. Kuznetsov // Teoriya poznaniya i sovremennaya nauka. – M.: Mysl, 1967. – S. 3–73.



17. Makaev E.A. Obshchaya teoriya sravnitelnogo yazykoznaniya [General theory of comparative linguistics] / Enver Akhmedovich Makaev. – M.: Nauka, 1977. – 205 s.



18. Makushev V. [Rets.:] M.A. Kolosov. Obzor zvukovykh i formalnykh osobennostey narodnogo russkogo yazyka. Varshava, 1878 [Overview of the sound and formal features of the folk Russian language. Varshava, 1878] / V. Makushev // Zhurn. m-va nar. prosveshcheniya. – 1878. – Ch. 200. – No. 2. – S. 363–381.



19. Meye A. Vvedenie v sravnitelnoe izuchenie indoevropeyskikh yazykov [Introduction to comparative study of Indo-European languages] / A. Meye; [pod red. i s primech. R. Shor]. – M.; L.: Sotsekgiz, 1938. – 510 s.



20. Melnikov G.P. Lingvisticheskie vozzreniya A.A. Potebni i tipologiya yazykov [The linguistic views of A.A. Potebnia and the typology of languages] / G.P. Melnikov // Naukova spadshchyna O.O. Potebnі і suchasna fіlologіia. Do 150-rіchchya z dnia narodzhennia O.O. Potebnі: [zb. nauk. Prats] / [vіdp. red. V.Yu. Franchuk]. – K.: Nauk. dumka, 1985. – S. 65–89.



21. Melnikov G.P. Sistemnaya lingvistika Humboldta – Sreznevskogo – Potebni – Boduena i sovremennaya sistemnaya tipologiya yazykov [System linguistics of Humboldt – Sreznevskiy –Potebnya – Boduen and modern system typology of languages] / G.P. Melnikov // Problemy tipologicheskoy, funktsionalnoy i opisatelnoy lingvistiki: [sb. nauch. Trudov]. – M.: Izd-vo Un-ta druzhby narodov, 1986. – S. 13–26.



22. Nadezhdin N.I. Velikaya Rossiya [The great Russia] / N.I. Nadezhdin // Entsiklopedicheskiy leksikon. – SPb., 1837. – S. 263– 276.



23. Pavskiy G.P. Filologicheskie nablyudeniya nad sostavom russkogo yazyka: pervoe rassuzhdenie. O bukvakh i slogakh [Philological observations of the composition of the Russian language: the first contemplation. About letters and syllables] / G.P. Pavskiy. – [2-e izd.]. – SPb., 1850. – ХХІІІ, 141 s.



24. Porzhezinskiy V.K. Vvedenie v yazykovedenie: [posobie k lektsiyam] [Introduction to linguistics: [a guidance for lectures]] / V.K. Porzhezinskiy. – [4-e izd.]. – M., 1916. – 243 s.



25. Postovalova V.I. Istoricheskaya fonologiya i ee osnovaniya: opyt logiko-metodologicheskogo analiza [Historical phonology and its foundations: the experience of logical-methodological analysis] / Valentina Ivanovna Postovalova. – M.: Nauka, 1978. – 203 s.



26. Serebrennikov B.A. Problema vzaimootnosheniya obshchey metodologii, lingvisticheskoy nauki i chastnykh metodov lingvisticheskogo issledovaniya [The problem of the correlation between general methodology, linguistic science and peculiar methods of linguistic research] / B.A. Serebrennikov // Obshchee yazykoznanie: metody lingvisticheskikh issledovaniy / [otv. red. B.A. Serebrennikov]. – M.: Nauka, 1973. – S. 257–313.



27. Smirnov S.V. Fedor Ivanovich Buslaev (1818–1897) [Fedor Ivanovich Buslaev (1818–1897)] / S.V. Smirnov. – M.: Izd-vo Mosk. un-ta, 1978. – 96 s.



28. Smirnov S.N. Elementy filosofskogo soderzhaniya ponyatiya “sistema” kak stupeni poznaniya i obshchestvennoy praktiki [Elements of the philosophical content of the concept of “system” as stages of cognition and social practice] / S.N. Smirnov // Sistemnyy analiz i nauchnoe znanie / [otv. red. D.P. Gorskiy]. – M.: Nauka, 1978. – S. 60–83.



29. Sorokin Yu.S. Evolyutsiya ponyatiya istorizma v russkom yazykoznanii 1830–1840-kh gg. [Evolution of the concept of historicism in Russian linguistics of the 1830–1840-s.] / Yu.S. Sorokin // Ponimanie istorizma i razvitiya v yazykoznanii pervoy poloviny XIX veka / [otv. red. A.V. Desnitskaya]. – L.: Nauka, 1984. – S. 200–235.



30. Sreznevskiy I.I. Istoriya russkogo yazyka [History of the Russian language]: kurs 1849–50 goda. Sostavlyal g. Chernyshevskiy / I.I. Sreznevskiy // Sreznevskiy I.I. Mysli ob istorii russkogo yazyka. – M.: Uchpedgiz, 1959. – S. 93–132.



31. Sreznevskiy I.I. Mysli ob istorii russkogo yazyka [Thoughts about history of the Russian language] / Sreznevskiy I.I. – M.: Uchpedgiz, 1959. – S. 16–81.



32. Chemodanov N.S. Sravnitelnoe yazykoznanie v Rossii: ocherk razvitiya sravnitelno-istoricheskogo metoda v russkom yazykoznanii [Comparative linguistics in Russia: an Eesay on the development of the comparative historical method in Russian linguistics] / N.S. Chemodanov. – M.: Uchpedgiz, 1956. – 95 s.
Published
2018-05-11
How to Cite
K.A. Tyshchenko, V. G. (2018, May 11). Formation of Causal and Systemic Relations in the Ukrainian and Russian Comparative Studies in 20th – 60th of the XIX c. Scientific Journal of National Pedagogical Dragomanov University. Series 9. Current Trends in Language Development, (15), 7-17. Retrieved from https://sjnpu.com.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/71